Ian's Movie Reviews
Short Reviews of Movies, Board Games, and Other Stuff

Looper

Well that was quite the movie. Its strong and weak aspects are really pulling at me here as I try to form an overall opinion. So lets start off by talking about why this movie is great. Then I can talk about why its not.

It takes balls to tackle a serious time travel story, since its a formula which is ripe for plotholes. But Looper does a pretty good job in keeping the overhanging science fiction ideas in place. The sci-fi aspect to this movie is pretty solid and very engaging. The film is set in 2044. Time Travel hasn’t been invented yet, but they know that it will be in the future. Crime syndicates use this idea to dispose of bodies in the past by employing people like Joe, played by both Joseph Gordon Levitt and Bruce Willis.

Both Levitt and Willis are great here. Lots is being said about the prosthetics used on Levitt to make him a younger Willis, and I thought I would be distracted by it but I ended up appreciating it. This appreciation may also come from how Levitt is actually able to become a younger Willis through his mannerisms and line delivery as well.

The time travel plot has quite a few layers to it and the idea of having two versions of the same person living in the same time allows for some really neat ideas, such as torturing one and affecting the other, or new memories appearing to old Joe as they happen to new Joe. This futuristic world is well-constructed in its ideas. In fact, the film’s high concept is enough to shoot it into the annals of great science fiction films.

What prevents the movie from rising so high however is its lack of focus. This movie is not very cohesive and by the time we reach the second half, its really all over the map, like a patchwork of sci-fi clutter.
Suddenly, what started off as being important isn’t any more, and a small detail from the world set-up has now become the primary plot driver. Instead of being about the two Joe’s suddenly its about this kid. Instead of feeling sympathetic for old Joe, suddenly we can`t any more because he does something unforgivable. And the ending is left far too open, and not in a good way like in Inception.

Its unconventional in the direction the plot takes, but it also feels like threads unravelling a bit. Yet perhaps time itself will prove me wrong, and this movie will endure as one of the great sci-fi films of this decade. We shall see. A very good film, but I’m not convinced of its greatness just yet.
8/10

Advertisements

6 Responses to “Looper”

  1. I dont know if I’d agree that it’s suddenly all over the map… but I will grant you that that “Small Detail” becoming a bigger part of the story is going to test the audience. And the child does take on a large role, but that’s not insurmountable by any means.

    I still think you can feel sympathetic for Old Joe, he’s been driven to a point where he does something he cant live with, in order to protect the life of someone he loves. Its gut wrenching.

    The ending isn’t really as open as you allude to… I think it wraps up nicely, the Loop is now a line.

    You wind up giving it a fair grade, I would just have to take issues with some of the specifics you mentioned. 😀

    • I don’t know man, I just can’t accept what he does. He basically is okay with taking the lives of two innocent children in the hope that he can gain a few more years with his wife. I can’t get on board. He becomes the villain that that point, which maybe he is supposed to?

  2. Hurm, I don’t share your main criticism, though I understand why that bothered you. Sorry you didn’t like this as much as everyone else, I’m glad you find some enjoyment here though.

  3. I have to ditto Fogs’ comment here. I was going to type it out, but then I read it and he summed up what I was thinking.

    I thought the ending really “closed the loop” as it were, myself.

    glad to see the score you gave it, however.

  4. I hear ya Ian, I was quite taken aback by the fact that Joe went so far as killing a child, though the film shows how much it shocked him as well. It was a last resort thing but he felt like he needed to protect the other loopers from suffering from the same fate as him. I don’t think he became the ‘villain’ necessarily, as some people might opt to take drastic measures to protect those they love.

    In any case, glad you at least appreciate the film. 8/10 is still pretty stellar, I thought you were going to give it a 6 or something 🙂

  5. […] Movie Project Time for a Film Cinema Nerdz Cinema Enthusiast Reel Talk Alex’s Movie Blog Ian’s Lists, Bits, and Reels 3 Guys 1 Movie The Film Corner Anti-Film School The Cinematic Spectacle Fr. Dennis at the Movies […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: